The Red Tent
Overview and Analysis
The first fiction novel that Anita Diamant wrote explores the lives of women in biblical times. In The Red Tent the main character Dinah, the only daughter in Jacob’s tribe, narrates her perception of life within Jacob’s family. She discusses the roles of the men and women in the community and how the women have had a major impact in her life. As the only female offspring in her generation, Dinah is pampered and given much attention to by her mothers and the women in the tribe. The power of the relationships between the female characters in the novel influenced Dinah’s future.
Later in the novel Dinah falls in love with the Prince of Shechem, named Shalem. This is the famous biblical story known as the “Rape of Dinah.” But in this fiction novel, Diamant portrays that Dinah is in love with the prince and that she was not a victim of a horrible crime. Two of Dinah’s brothers murder Shalem. This upsets Dinah so much that she curses her family and moves to Egypt with her mother-in-law. There she gives birth to Re-mose, son of the prince. After a time, Dinah remarries to a carpenter named Benia. Dinah becomes happy with her new family and is also a renowned midwife in the town. She lives out her days and dies a happy woman.
This novel holds many themes that relate to our course. It addresses patriarchy and the male-centric perspective of the Bible, gender roles in that society, and essentialism. The book, even though it was not an attempt to fill in the gaps in the Bible, provides the woman’s viewpoint of the stories in the Bible. This avoids the male-centric narrative by replacing it with the narrative of Dinah, the only daughter in Jacob’s tribe. Within this patriarchal society, Dinah found refuge with the women in the family. She escaped from the male canon to explore the female relations that helped hold the family together. This can be related to the gender roles that were present in the Biblical times. In the story and in the Bible, the female members of the community were required to cook and run the family camps while the males tend to the flocks or farms and provide the income for the family. The women also cared for the girls in the family while the men cared for the boys. The boys would play games that were meant for boys and they would learn how to tend to the flock or become an apprentice in their father’s line of work. The same process was used to rear the girls. They would follow their mothers around and learn the trade secrets of keeping the camp and cooking for the family, much like Dinah did in the novel. This also plays into the concept of essentialism. Women were supposed to give birth and care for children, while men were supposed to be source of income for the family. The idea was that the women had the personality and skills for being at home to be caring and loving for the household while men had the strength and capacity for gaining financial and political success. It was biologically imprinted into the society for the separation of gender within the community.
These multiple themes can fall into the broader category that has been studied throughout the course. This is social construction. All of these ideas came out of the social construction of the authors of the Bible. Diamant takes these ideas and transforms them through the eyes of a female character who must follow those rules of society. It is an interesting book because it takes the this female perspectives and gives an interpretation of Biblical stories. It is another way to view the Bible and is an innovative and influential piece in literature. 2
Being somewhat religious, I could imagine The Red Tent could be a very interesting book--seeing that it takes a woman's view on the stories of the bible. However, it would probably be pretty confusing if you are not familiar with the bible and it's characters. Was it hard for you guys to relate? Also, do you know if this book caused any controversy from its viewpoint?
ReplyDeleteHer second book seems almost entirely different that her first... which one did you like better?
As Krista said, I think this would be a really interesting book if you are familiar with the bible and all its stories. I know Anita is jewish, but what really inspired her to rewrite bible stories in the female perspective? Also, I didn't understand well how patriarchy plays a role in this book.
ReplyDeleteWhen I read this I think: What woman would want to portray a rape as something other then what it is? Was there something that happened to her or someone she knew that could have possibly made her think or what she wishes to think happened? And what I mean is, did she get raped and wanted so badly for it not to happen that she chooses to think that she was in love with him?
ReplyDeleteI am also confused to which bible this post relates to. The gender roles of this was explained for us readers to understand but patriarchy was not explained that well. I am not too religious personally but with it being related to the bible did it cause the book to be unwanted by the religious groups or attract them towards it?
ReplyDeleteThat last comment was from Brian Vorel
ReplyDeleteKrista,
ReplyDeleteI am not very religious so I did not relate to the Biblical background very well at all. I feel that I would have been able to understand the themes and messages in the novel better if I had read the story of Genesis and the Bible. But I do know that this topic did cause controversy. Critics claimed that Diamant was trying to change stories from the Bible and that was being a radical by writing this novel. Religion is always so controversial and this book definitely stirred up some debate. And as for the Good Harbor, I did not read that so I have no opinion on which book was better. I know that The Red Tent is Diamant's most famous novel though.
Thanks for your comment!
Giovanna,
I believe that Diamant was just exploring her faith. She was and still is really involved in Judaism and just provides a female perspective on a very male-centric piece of work. There are a lot of women that are mentioned in the Bible that have no story so Diamant wanted to experiment with what it would have been like for women in Biblical times. This is the best motivator I can find behind her desire to write The Red Tent.
The patriarchy comes in because Dinah actually lives in a patriarchal society. The themes from the Bible conclude that men have the power and men make decisions that control their own and women's lives. It was just to show that even though Diamant wrote from Dinah's perspective, she still lived in a man's world.
Thanks for your comment and I hope that helps.
Brittany,
I cannot find any history of Diamant being raped or abused in her life. The idea of this part of the novel is to review the male perspective story from the Bible that says Dinah was raped. If you try to avoid thinking about what the author of the Bible wrote down as his truth and look at the female perspective of what could be another truth then maybe Dinah was not actually raped but in love with her partner. This is a touchy subject again but I think Diamant was stating that we believe what the author wrote as to be true, when it is possible that her novel could be the real story. It is another way to interpret a story of history that we really can't prove and say that those events actually happened.
Thanks for you comment and I hope this gives a better description of Diamant's goal.
Brian,
Again the issue of religion is a very touchy and controversial subject to address. There was resistance against this book by people who believe strictly in the Bible's word as truth. So this definitely stirred up some debate. But people also took a liking to the novel because it did become a best seller. So its definitely high up on the list for a Bible vs. anti-Bible debate. But Diamant was not trying to rewrite the Bible in any means, she just wanted to open the idea of female perspective within the male-centric world of the Bible.
Thanks for you comment.
This sounds like a great novel as you've described it. I think that it is remarkable that Diamant is courageous enough to somewhat "translate" women's roles in the Bible. After all though it is that courageous aspect that makes writers unique. Great work here.
ReplyDelete-Patrick Ernst
I read The Red Tent a few years ago and really enjoyed it, but one of the themes that I noticed, aside from the influence of patriarchy, gender roles, and social contructs that you explored, was the idea of the importance of storytelling. Not only was Diamant telling us, the readers, a story from an unheard perspective, but within the story itself, Dinah becomes the main means of preservation for the stories of her aunts and mother. The women around her seek her out to share with her their experiences, histories, knowledge, and tales of their ancestors. But based on what we've discussed in class and looking at the novel, how do you think women's ability to tell their stories and preserve their histories have been helped or hurt by social constructs and gender roles, if at all?
ReplyDelete--Gabrielle Karcheski
Patrick,
ReplyDeleteThanks for your comment and yes, Diamant does have some guts! I am glad you liked the blog.
Gabrielle,
I appreciate your input on the novel. I am glad you could bring the theme of story telling to my attention because I was really focused on the major topics discussed in class. I overlooked this simple yet very important theme of the novel. Story telling is an important part of any society and is an act that helps teach children the morals and values of that society. When talking about women being storytellers in a nationally or internationally recognized sense like a best selling author, I think that they have been hurt by our social construct. I do not think female story tellers have had an equal opportunity to men to present themselves and their skills to a wider audience. It is becoming more common to see female writers recognized on a large scale, but traditionally I do not think they had the same support. However, I do think that in a smaller structure such as a family or a small community the female storyteller is accredited. In families the mother usually tells children stories or reads them books, at least from my perspective. In a smaller society such as this, the female has been helped. The father is not the one to be as nurturing or caring or the story teller as the mother. So this gives the female storyteller the opportunity to thrive, even if it is at a local level and even if it is just with her children. I think the social construct in our society defines traits of a female at different structural levels so even though one outlook, such as a national standard, may be one way, another, such as the family or small community, could produce another view.
Thanks for your thoughtful comment and I appreciate your input on this novel.